The words 5 places in large serif type, the five places a crypto tax report overstates the gain
Explainerone question answered

Your crypto tax report says you owe tax but you lost money. Both can be true, and five errors make it worse

Fahad Zar, photographed against a plain background, head and shoulders
Fahad ZarCrypto tax accountant, licensed and regulated by the AAT. MSc Accounting and Finance, BPP University London. Six years reconciling wallet and exchange histories for UK filings.

Published 10 November 2026 Reviewed against gov.uk 10 November 2026 9 min readCrypto Tax

The words 5 places in large serif type, the five places a crypto tax report overstates the gain

Both things can be true at once. Your portfolio is worth less than it was on 6 April, and your tax report says you owe capital gains tax for the year. The tax is charged on each disposal you made during the year, and the fall in the coins you still hold is not a loss until you sell them. So a year of selling winners in the summer and holding losers into the spring produces a tax bill and a smaller portfolio together.

That is the part the report has right. The part it often has wrong is the size of the gain. Software that reads every exchange export and wallet address it is given still has to guess what a movement between two addresses was, and what you paid for a coin whose purchase it never saw. When it guesses badly the gain goes up, never down. This page gives the five places that happens, how to find each one in your own file, and what a corrected year looks like.

A falling portfolio and a tax bill can both be true, because the tax falls on what you sold and swapped, not on what you still hold. Before you pay, check the five places a report inflates the gain. Transfers read as sales, nil costs, wrong pooling, dropped fees and doubled trades.

Why you can owe tax in a losing year

Capital gains tax is worked out disposal by disposal. HMRC’s Cryptoassets Manual at CRYPTO22100 lists what counts as a disposal, selling tokens for money, exchanging tokens for a different type of token, using tokens to pay for goods or services, and giving tokens away to anyone other than a spouse or civil partner. The swap is the one that catches people. Moving from ether into solana in July, when both had risen, is a disposal of the ether at its sterling value that day, and the gain on it is taxed even though no pounds ever reached your bank account. If solana then fell by March, that fall belongs to the solana you still hold and has not yet been realised.

Swaps into a stablecoin work the same way. Selling ether for USDC at a peak crystallises the ether gain. Swapping the USDC back later is a disposal of the USDC, which held its value, so it produces no loss to set against the gain. The guide to crypto tax when you never sold for pounds works through four of these.

The tax year boundary does the rest. A gain realised in March 2026 and a loss realised in April 2026 sit in different years. The gain is taxed on the return due by 31 January 2027, and the loss waits for the following return, where it can be carried back to nothing and only forward.

The five places a report overstates the gain

One. A transfer between your own wallets read as a sale. CRYPTO22100 says there is no disposal if you retain beneficial ownership of the tokens throughout, and gives moving tokens between public addresses you control as the example. Software only knows that when it can see both ends of the movement. If the receiving wallet was never added, or the amounts differ by a network fee, the outgoing side is recorded as a sale at market value against your pooled cost, and a gain appears that never happened. The guide to moving crypto between wallets explains the test.

Two. A coin with no purchase record. When the software never saw you buy something it sells, it gives it a cost of nil, and the entire sale price becomes gain. CRYPTO22150 allows the consideration in pound sterling originally paid for the asset, plus the transaction fee for putting the transaction on the ledger, among other costs. The purchase usually exists somewhere, on an exchange that has since closed, in a bank statement showing the card payment, or on the chain. CRYPTO10400 puts the duty to keep those records on you, and notes that exchanges may only keep records for a short period or may no longer exist, which is exactly why the gap arises.

Three. Pooling not applied, or applied to the wrong lots. UK rules do not let you choose which coins you sold. CRYPTO22200 puts every token of one type into a single pool under section 104 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 at an averaged cost, after matching the disposal first against anything bought the same day and then against anything bought in the following 30 days under section 106A. Software set to another country’s method, or left on a first in first out default, produces a different gain for every single disposal, and in a rising market the difference is usually against you.

Four. Fees not deducted. The table at CRYPTO22150 sets out which exchange fees are allowable and against what. A fee paid in the token being sold reduces the proceeds, a fee paid to acquire adds to the cost, and a network fee on a transfer between your own wallets is a disposal of the fee tokens in its own right. Reports that drop fees altogether, or treat the fee tokens as if they were still held, overstate the year.

Five. The same transaction counted twice. This one comes from the files rather than any manual. An exchange connected by API and by a CSV export of the same account shows every trade twice. A wallet added by address and again through a bridge or a DeFi tracker shows every movement twice. Doubling the trades roughly doubles the gain, and the report looks confident while it does it.

How to check your own report in an hour

Open the disposals list and sort by cost. Every disposal with a cost of nil is either a genuine airdrop or fork, or a missing purchase. Then filter for transfers and withdrawals. Any withdrawal to an address you own that is recorded as a sale is place one. Then look at the end of year holdings the report thinks you have, and compare them with what your wallets and exchanges actually showed on 5 April. A report that believes you hold two bitcoin more than you do has counted something twice, and one that believes you hold less has treated a transfer as a sale. Last, check the settings. The cost basis method should read share pooling, and the tax year should run 6 April to 5 April.

The gov.uk guidance on tax when you sell cryptoassets, last updated 5 October 2026, says of exchange reports that they are not tax calculations and will not keep track of your pooled costs. The same is true of the software report built on top of them until each of the five places has been checked.

A corrected year, with figures

Suppose your report for the year to 5 April 2026 shows a gain of £14,000, and your holdings fell by a third over the same year. Three movements of ether from an exchange to your hardware wallet were recorded as sales and produced £5,200 of the gain. Half an ether bought for £1,200 on an exchange that closed in 2023 carried a nil cost, so its sale for £1,500 showed as a £1,500 gain rather than £300. Correcting those two places takes the gain to £7,600. Against the £3,000 allowance that is £4,600 taxable, and at the 18% rate inside the basic rate band the tax is £828, where the report implied £1,980. The portfolio still fell. The tax is still due. The number is £1,152 smaller because it is now the right one.

The reverse happens too. A report that treats a swap as a transfer, or misses a disposal on a chain it was never given, understates the gain, and that is the version HMRC finds when the exchange data arrives under the Cryptoasset Reporting Framework from 31 May 2027. The point of checking is to file the true figure, whichever way it moves.

If the loss is real, claim it

A loss on a disposal is deducted from gains of the same year first. If losses exceed gains, the balance carries forward to set against future gains, but only once it has been claimed. The gov.uk losses page says you claim by including the loss on your tax return, or by writing to HMRC if you have never made a gain and are not registered for Self Assessment, and that you can claim up to four years after the end of the tax year in which you disposed of the asset. Losses from the year to 5 April 2023 therefore have to be claimed by 5 April 2027. The guide to claiming capital losses covers the mechanics.

A token that has become worthless while you still hold it can also be claimed. CRYPTO22500 allows a negligible value claim that treats the tokens as disposed of and immediately reacquired at the value stated in the claim, which may be nil, and because tokens are pooled the claim is made for the whole pool. The resulting loss is reported in the normal way.

What to do before you pay

The return for the year to 5 April 2026 is due online with the tax by 31 January 2027. Fix the report before then, because a figure paid on a wrong report is only recovered by amending the return, and a figure under-declared is found later with interest and a penalty attached. If the five checks above throw up more than a handful of items, the reconciliation is a job rather than an afternoon, and the fees for it are below. The first look at your report is free and tells you which it is.

Three fixed fees, quoted in writing before any work starts

One taxpayer, one tax year unless the line says otherwise. Written position within 15 working days of software access.

Review and file
For an exchange-only history under about 5,000 trades where the software report is already built.
£499
Computation
For several platforms, wallet transfers read as sales, duplicates, and one or two back years.
£950
Reconciliation
For DeFi, derivatives, high volume, or balances that do not tie.
£1,750
Multi-year rebuild, staged. Several years, an HMRC letter, an exchange data notice, or a return that was never filed. From £3,450 in two stages, half at signing, with the second stage priced once the first is done.

Send your software report to zar@certifiedcryptoaccountant.com for a written fee the same working day, or start with the free review. Licensed and regulated by the AAT, licence 1010475.

Questions about a report that looks wrong

Can I really owe capital gains tax if my crypto is worth less than I paid?

Yes. HMRC taxes each disposal in the year, and selling or swapping tokens for a different token is a disposal under CRYPTO22100. Gains on the disposals you made are taxed even if the coins you kept fell afterwards, because an unrealised fall is not a loss until you dispose of those coins.

Why does my crypto tax software show a gain on a transfer to my own wallet?

Because it could not see both ends of the movement. HMRC's manual says there is no disposal when you move tokens between addresses you control, but software records the outgoing side as a sale unless the receiving wallet is added and the amounts match. Adding the wallet and matching the transfer removes the gain.

What happens if the software does not know what I paid for a coin?

It gives the coin a cost of nil, so the whole sale price becomes gain. CRYPTO22150 allows the sterling you actually paid plus allowable fees, so the cost can be rebuilt from a bank statement, an old exchange export or the chain record and the gain corrected.

Does my crypto tax software use the right UK method?

Only if it is set to share pooling with the same day and 30 day rules, which is the UK method under sections 104, 105 and 106A of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992. First in first out, last in first out and specific identification are other countries' methods and give different gains on every disposal.

How long do I have to claim a crypto loss?

Up to four years after the end of the tax year in which you disposed of the asset, per gov.uk. You claim on your tax return, or by writing to HMRC if you have never made a gain and are not in Self Assessment. A worthless token you still hold can be claimed through a negligible value claim for the whole pool.

Sources

Every figure on this page was checked against the source below on 10 November 2026.

  1. CRYPTO22100, Capital Gains Tax, what is a disposal. HM Revenue and Customs, checked 10 November 2026
  2. CRYPTO22150, Capital Gains Tax, allowable expenses. HM Revenue and Customs, checked 10 November 2026
  3. CRYPTO22200, Capital Gains Tax, pooling. HM Revenue and Customs, checked 10 November 2026
  4. CRYPTO22500, section 24 and negligible value. HM Revenue and Customs, checked 10 November 2026
  5. CRYPTO10400, record keeping. HM Revenue and Customs, checked 10 November 2026
  6. Check if you need to pay tax when you sell cryptoassets. HM Revenue and Customs, checked 10 November 2026
  7. Capital Gains Tax, if you make a loss. GOV.UK, checked 10 November 2026
  8. Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992, section 104. legislation.gov.uk, checked 10 November 2026
  9. Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992, section 106A. legislation.gov.uk, checked 10 November 2026
Fahad Zar, photographed against a plain background, head and shoulders

Fahad Zar

Crypto tax accountantAAT licensed 1010475

  • AAT Licensed Accountant and MAAT, licence 1010475
  • MSc Accounting and Finance, BPP University London
  • Six years inside digital asset accounting, across several crypto tax firms
  • Practises through Zar Enterprises Ltd, ICO registration ZC225094
  • Supervised for anti-money laundering by the AAT

What matters to me is that the number on the return is true, whatever it turns out to be.

Whether this is worth a conversation

Where this stops being a reading job and starts being a hiring one.

  • Your report shows a gain you do not believe and the return is due by 31 January 2027
  • Transfers to your own wallets appear as sales, or disposals carry a nil cost, and you cannot see how to fix them
  • You used more than one exchange or chain and the end of year holdings in the report do not match what you actually hold

If every transfer is matched, no disposal carries a nil cost, the method reads share pooling and the closing holdings match your wallets, the report is probably right. File it and keep the exports behind it.

If one of these is you, the first look costs nothing.

Claim the free health check

Read next

Deep guide

Why crypto tax software gets UK returns wrong

What the tools do well, where they fail, and how to read the output.

Reviewed 10 November 2026
Explainer

Do you pay tax moving crypto between wallets

The beneficial ownership test and the network fee that is a disposal.

Reviewed 10 November 2026
Deep guide

How to claim unclaimed capital losses

The four year window, the claim itself and carrying losses forward.

Reviewed 10 November 2026
Deep guide

What crypto records HMRC expects you to keep

The records that rebuild a missing cost when the exchange has gone.

Reviewed 10 November 2026
Explainer

Missing purchase history means the software gave your coins a nil cost. Here is how to find the real one

The nil cost problem on its own page. Why the warning appears, what HMRC lets you count as cost, and a worked example at 18% and 24%.

Reviewed 11 November 2026
Explainer

Fixing a crypto tax report costs £499, £950 or £1,750, and the look that decides which one is free

What fixing the report costs. Three fixed fees, the five things that decide which one, and the £14,000 file put beside its fee.

Reviewed 11 November 2026
Explainer

A negative balance means your crypto tax software sold coins it never saw you buy. How to clear it

The negative balance warning on its own page. The date the ledger went below zero tells you where the gap is, and a worked example at 18% and 24%.

Reviewed 12 November 2026
Explainer

Your tax report counted a transfer to your own wallet as a sale. Moving coins is not a disposal. The fix

The transfer read as a sale on its own page. Why the pair breaks, the gain it invents on the day of the move, and a worked example across two tax years.

Reviewed 12 November 2026

Similar Posts